Jump to content

CG Ideas/Proposals - Theme: Emergency


Recommended Posts

Hey, CG Command, Lawrance here.

Is CG really useful in emergencies regarding the protection of VIPs?
The answer is n o.


In case of an emergency, such as DEFCON 1, CG are tasked with evacuating with fleet. Now, you can already see the problem. Unless a CG is pilot trained, all we can do is literally just follow the VIPs to a vehicle which any fleet can literally spawn. Let me rephrase it this way; our jobs can most literally be done by those who we are supposed to protect and they can do it better in most cases.
This also doesn't touch on the case of if a VIP is down during the evacuation which all a CG can do is maybe call a medic and watch the corpse of the body, looking at the literal failure of their role. Well, no more!
Say Hello to the CG first aid kit and CG emergency LAAT!
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1pvQLTXDc6dX0uz41WXyEa7FFIfd_LLTJoxrSnvQdLEc/edit

Please for the love of god and everything holy, please give feedback because otherwise this cannot simply work with me alone, thanks ❤️

Link to post
Share on other sites

wait so... let me get this clear, do CG get both of these things... or is it just a singular?... and... couldn't the CG just get a medical or pilots license... like every other regiment?

Link to post
Share on other sites

-1
I disagree with the problems presented in the document, firstly your troops can be trained to be pilot and medics, there isn't a need for them to be special when its available your regiment just cant be bothered to get the training for it. Although the one time revive would be a cool idea but making every CG SGT+ would make it more standard then for emergency situations.

Link to post
Share on other sites

They can but if they choose to simply be Pilot, it will lock them out of literally doing their jobs. Before base police, cg are guards and unless all of CG is medic trained, there is nothing to do about a VIP who die.
Why shouldn't we call Medics instead if that be the case? As I said, it's literally our job to protect those VIPs and it makes CG a joke as this implies our jobs can easily be filled by a 501st, as to say anyone with shields can do as good of a job defending a VIP as us.

Link to post
Share on other sites

if all CG are medically trained, that removes the risk CG take, and for the most part removes the fun of CG. If there is literally 0 risk, 0 consequence if a VIP downs, where's the fun in it? CGs attraction during VIP guarding is working hard to protect the VIP, making sure they survive, making them earn a promotion. instead of vip guy die, revive spammmmmmmmm because we're all medics  but with giving all of CG LAATs and Medical equipment, it defeats the purpose of the license system, it should be down to regimental management to have CG with the licenses . 501st have their own priorities, if you cant make your regiment follow the basis, and make the other regiment their own priorities, then that seems like a Command issue, not a issue within the regiment themself. 

Link to post
Share on other sites

Cud I don't know how carefully you've read it but I never said they should all be spamming revives or they should just get LAATs. I specifically said the revive for example should be a one time use that only gets you up to 50 HP with no armour. And the LAATs are for evacuation purposes only, meaning even if there were to be an order, unless it is an emergency evacuation, CG would not spawn it.

The problem comes down to no matter how hard I would train CG for shield use, people will die. Although clones wouldn't be of worry, when VIP or more specifically MCOs and Fleet were to go down, it means we failed to do our duty and when shields can't stop the explosion radius of weapons, that makes us nothing but meatshields. If this is a command issue then it's not one that I can fix as I don't believe I can actually train anyone to be able to shield off every damage.

Link to post
Share on other sites

-1  CG have the option of being trained to be a Pilot or Medic at SGT+ which solves both of the problems you mention, without needing to add a medkit to all CG (which makes normal medics/medics within CG pointless), or them need to have a special LAAT (which would still require Pilot training to fly, thus making the trooper a pilot anyway?), on top of this most pilots and medics generaly can do the exact things you are asking for CG, all you would really need is to ask them nicely/for them to be nearby.

Edited by [PU] FurrDazzler
Link to post
Share on other sites

I don't understand how far you've read the Doc knowing I don't think you would go ahead and say Medics who can heal you, fix injuries and revive you to full health would be the same as one time med kit which revives you 50 hp only. And neither do I understand how CG getting transportation LAAT for literally one purpose would be competing with full pilot permissions.

Entirely it makes it so if they choose to lock themselves in one area, they can still be useful as a CG.
Am I saying getting a pilot and getting a medic won't solve this? In theory, it would but that does NOT hold up in practice when the entire CG would rarely be on at the same time as well as play as CG. I can't expect them to do exactly what I need them to do but I do expect them to be able to perform as CG.
And I'm not even mentioning how pathetic it makes CG to be relying on being specialised to literally perform what we need to do to begin with.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Heavy -1.

You are a defense regiment. You shouldn't be reliant on one-time defibs when your job is to protect the person from dying in the first place. If they die, acknowledge you failed and call a medic.

If you want to fly as a CG, get a pilot license.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Due to -1 by the most or/and all people these proposals are most related to, these ideas will be scratched. Thank you for your feedback! ❤️

Link to post
Share on other sites

Your suggestion/bug report has now changed status to denied, see the replies to this topic for the reason. If your bug report was denied, it is because it was not able to be re-produced by a member of the development team, or because you submitted a bug report that is invalid and either will not be fixed, or is not fixable (such as asking us to fix an issue with the game itself).

Thank you for taking your time to write your suggestion/bug report.

Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
×
×
  • Create New...